The market gives the same information to everyone. News channels, stock screeners, brokerage reports — all free, all accessible. Yet most Indian investors still end up losing money. Which means the market is not the problem.
If you have ever felt that the stock market is rigged, or that only the big players win, you are not alone. That feeling is common. But it is also, as it turns out, factually incorrect — and believing it is actually one of the reasons why retail investors keep making the same mistakes, year after year.
Let us start with a number that SEBI published — and that most people quietly looked away from.
93% of individual F&O traders in India lose money.Over three years studied by SEBI, these traders collectively lost over ₹1.81 lakh crore. Not a market crash. Not a fraud. Just ordinary retail participation — applied the wrong way.
Source: SEBI Study on Profit and Loss of Individual Traders in Equity F&O Segment, 2023.
Now here is the more important question: were these 93% people without access to information? No. Were they uneducated? Largely, no. Did they not have smartphones, internet, broking apps? They had all of it.
So why did they lose? Because the problem was never information. The problem was the approach — the mental model with which they entered the market in the first place.
The Three Wrong Approaches Most Indian Investors Use
Across conversations with hundreds of retail investors, a clear pattern emerges. Most people who consistently lose money in the markets are not unlucky. They are following one of three broken approaches — often without even realising it.
The Reframe That Changes Everything
Think about the chai shop at the corner of your street. The owner knows exactly what it costs to make one cup — milk, tea, sugar, gas, labour. He knows what his daily footfall is. He knows which months are slow. He does not check a ticker every fifteen minutes to know if his business is doing well. He looks at his costs, his customers, and his cash.
A stock is simply a small ownership stake in a business. When you buy a share of a company, you are not buying a number on a screen. You are buying a claim on that company’s future earnings — its profits, its growth, its management’s decisions over years and decades.
“When you buy a share of a company, you are not buying a number on a screen. You are buying a claim on that company’s future earnings.”
The investors who consistently build wealth over time — whether it is Warren Buffett in Omaha or Rakesh Jhunjhunwala in Mumbai — all approached the market the same way. They studied businesses. They understood what the company sold, who it sold to, how it made money, and whether the people running it were trustworthy. Then they waited — patiently — for the business to perform.
This is not a secret formula. It is not genius. It is a learnable process. The reason most Indian investors have never tried it is simple: nobody taught them.
Why Information Is Not Enough
We live in an era of information abundance. Annual reports are publicly available. SEBI filings are free. Balance sheets are downloadable. Every listed company in India is legally required to disclose its financials every quarter.
And yet, this information goes largely unread — because most investors do not know what to look for, how to interpret what they find, or how to connect a company’s numbers to a buying or selling decision.
This is the real gap. Not information. Understanding.
The Stock Manthan Perspective
Stock Manthan was built on one simple idea: investing becomes less scary and more rational when you understand the business behind the stock. Not tips. Not predictions. Not promises. Just education — structured, calm, and designed for the Indian retail investor who is serious about doing this right.
So What Should You Do Differently?
Start with this shift: the next time you hear about a stock — from any source — before asking “what is the target price?”, ask “what does this company actually do, and how does it make money?”
That one question separates an investor from a speculator. It is the beginning of a completely different relationship with the market. One that is calmer, more informed, and — over time — significantly more rewarding.
The market is not your enemy. Your approach might be. And approaches, unlike the market, can be changed.
Understanding why Indian investors lose money is step one. The far more interesting part is learning what the investors who win consistently are actually doing — and building that same process for yourself, one concept at a time.
Start Learning the Right Way
Join Stock Manthan’s free WhatsApp learning community — or watch the complimentary recorded session on how to evaluate a business before you invest in it.
Watch Free Session